Founder's Guide 101 - What Happens to the Stock When you Sell your Startup?

The world of startups is a dynamic and thrilling space where new businesses are born, grow, and often end up on the acquisition radar.

For everyone involved—from the founders to the team members to the investors—the acquisition phase is a pivotal moment that raises a significant concern: What happens to the company's stock? This question isn't just about the numbers; it's deeply personal, too, as the stock symbolizes the culmination of immense effort, investment, and aspirations.

Our new article is designed to be your go-to resource, offering a clear understanding of the potential fates of your stock when your startup is acquired. It provides critical insights to assist you in navigating this crucial juncture in your startup's journey and help you make well-informed choices.

Read More: IRS From 1120

‍

What are the Different Types of Startup Acquisitions?

Cash Transactions

When a startup is bought out in a cash transaction, the acquiring entity pays a specific cash sum for the company. This scenario typically spells good news for shareholders, who get a direct cash return on their shares. Yet, it's vital to grasp the tax consequences since such transactions are taxable.

Equity Exchanges

In this scenario, shareholders don't get cash; instead, they receive shares of the acquiring company. This arrangement can be beneficial as it defers immediate tax liabilities. The exchange rate of existing shares for new ones is set based on the acquisition terms and isn't always a one-for-one swap.

Hybrid Deals

Sometimes, acquisitions involve a mix of cash and stock, providing a middle ground for shareholders. This type allows shareholders to gain upfront cash and maintain a stake in the new, merged company, offering a blend of immediate and future value.

‍

Factors Affecting Your Stock During a Startup Acquisition

The destiny of your stock in a startup acquisition hinges on various elements, which can differ based on your equity type, employment contract clauses, and the acquisition's specifics. Below is an in-depth exploration of these critical factors:

Equity Classification

• Common Stock: Common stockholders typically receive payments after preferred stockholders and creditors. Nonetheless, a lucrative acquisition deal can also yield significant returns for common stockholders.
• Preferred Stock: Holders enjoy preferential treatment during payouts, often recovering their investments before any distributions to common stockholders.

Vesting Conditions

• Cliff Vesting: Should the acquisition occur before your cliff vesting period concludes, you might only receive benefits if your contract includes specific acceleration provisions.
• Gradual Vesting: With a staggered vesting schedule, you can receive proceeds from your vested shares. The treatment of unvested shares will align with the acquisition's conditions.

Vesting Acceleration Clauses

Employment agreements might feature clauses that expedite vesting upon an acquisition:

• Single-Trigger: This clause triggers full vesting with the company's sale.
• Double-Trigger: Vesting accelerates when the company is sold, and you're dismissed without a valid reason within a designated period post-sale.

Such clauses can significantly affect your financial gain, mainly if the acquisition occurs early in your vesting timeline.

Share Conversion Rates

In stock exchanges during acquisitions, your shares are converted into the acquirer's stock based on specific ratios, influencing your new ownership extent and possibly the rights that come with the new shares.

Holdback Agreements

Acquirers may use holdback arrangements, reserving a deal portion until the startup meets set post-acquisition benchmarks, which can affect the total shareholders receive.

Escrow Provisions

To safeguard against post-buyout liabilities, a part of the acquisition sum might be placed in escrow. While this secures the buyer, shareholders must wait for certain conditions to pass before accessing all their funds.

Market Dynamics

The broader economic and market environment can affect the acquisition, notably influencing stock prices in stock-for-stock deals.

Understanding these facets can equip you with the knowledge to navigate your stock's journey through a startup acquisition. However, consulting with financial and legal professionals is crucial for informed decision-making.

Understanding Legal and Tax Implications in a Startup Acquisition

For founders and employees, unraveling the legal and tax intricacies during a startup acquisition is pivotal. These elements can significantly influence your financial outcomes and future planning. Below is an exploration of the key legal and tax issues to consider:

Legal Considerations

Due Diligence: The acquirer's comprehensive review of your startup's legal documents, contracts, IP rights, and obligations is critical. Ensuring thorough and accurate documentation is essential to smooth the acquisition process.

Indemnification Provisions: These protect the buyer from potential post-acquisition liabilities related to your startup's past operations. Be mindful that part of the acquisition payment might be reserved in escrow to address these future liabilities.

Restrictive Covenants: Post-acquisition, you might face limitations on launching a similar venture or hiring from your previous company, usually for a specific timeframe.

IP Rights Assignment: Confirm that any IP you've developed, like patents or trademarks, is explicitly transferred under the acquisition terms to prevent future disputes.

Read More: IRS Form 7004

Tax Matters

Capital Gains Implications: Selling your shares for cash triggers capital gains taxes, with the rates varying based on whether your holdings are considered long- or short-term investments.

Stock Option Taxation: If you're contemplating exercising stock options pre-acquisition, be aware of the tax consequences. Consulting with a tax advisor can help you make informed decisions.

Tax Deferral Opportunities: Certain stock-for-stock deals may allow you to defer capital gains until you sell the acquired shares, contingent on the deal's structure and prevailing tax regulations.

AMT for ISOs: Exercising Incentive Stock Options could bring you under the Alternative Minimum Tax's scope, so assessing this impact in advance is crucial.

Taxation of Earn-Outs: Acquisition agreements might include taxable earn-outs based on future performance. The timing of these taxes can depend on the structure of the earn-outs.

Local and State Tax Variances: The tax consequences can also vary by state and locality, adding another layer to consider during the acquisition.

Note: Knowing the legal and tax sides of a startup buyout can safeguard your interests and guide your decisions. Getting advice from legal and tax pros is a smart move to make sure you're on track.

‍

Wrapping It Up

Jumping into a startup acquisition is like untangling a complex knot. Each part—whether it’s cash transactions, stock swaps, or hybrid deals—affects your outcome. Understanding all these elements is key to making smart, informed decisions.

For more information on bookkeeping for startups, check out Inkle Books. 

Say hello on LinkedIn.